Chris' Vinyl Picks
๐ŸŽต Lists By Genres
๐ŸŽ›๏ธ Care Guides
Dig by Category
๐ŸŽค Artist Deep Dive ๐Ÿ•บ Soul/Funk

Every Simon & Garfunkel Album Ranked Best to Worst

Simon & Garfunkel Cover

๐ŸŽง Artist Spotlight

Simon & Garfunkel

Dive deep into the essential discography of Simon & Garfunkel. Explore the defining studio albums that shaped their legendary career.

โšก Key Highlights of Article

  • Bridge over Troubled Water takes the top spot as the duo’s cinematic masterpiece.
  • Bookends showcases their most ambitious storytelling and concept-driven songwriting.
  • Their short five-album run in the 1960s remains one of the most consistent in pop history.
  • Early Columbia stereo pressings deliver incredible vocal warmth for vinyl listeners.
Curated Spotify PlaylistExpand Player โ–พ
๐Ÿ“‹ Vinyl Guide (5 Albums)Jump List โŒƒ

Few vocal duos in music history have ever captured human emotion and poetic beauty like Paul Simon and Art Garfunkel. Across a brief six-year run of studio albums, they evolved from humble acoustic folkies into global folk-rock superstars, leaving behind a flawless string of classic records.

Whether you are a longtime fan looking to complete your vinyl shelves or a newcomer crate-digging for timeless harmonies, ranking their catalogue is a joy. Every single album offers memorable melodies and stunning production details that shine on turntable setups.

Let’s spin through all five of Simon & Garfunkel’s official studio albums, ranking them from their acoustic beginnings to their ultimate artistic peak.

Essential Simon & Garfunkel Albums Ranked

#1 Essential Pick

Simon & Garfunkel โ€” Bridge over Troubled Water

Label: Columbia • Released: 1970

Simon & Garfunkel โ€” Bridge over Troubled Water

Label: Columbia • Released: 1970

Simon & Garfunkel bowed out at the absolute peak of their creative powers with this grand, timeless masterpiece. Blending gospel, pop, folk, and Latin rhythms, every single track feels like a iconic classic with flawless arrangements.

๐Ÿ”Š PREVIEW TOP TRACKS โŒ„
โ™ซ Bridge Over Troubled Water
โ™ซ The Boxer
โ™ซ Cecilia
๐Ÿชฉ Vinyl Pressing & Mastering Notes: Look for vintage Columbia 360 Sound pressings or high-end audiophile reissues for stunning vocal clarity.
#2 Essential Pick

Simon & Garfunkel โ€” Bookends

Label: Columbia • Released: 1968

Simon & Garfunkel โ€” Bookends

Label: Columbia • Released: 1968

A brilliantly crafted concept album exploring youth, aging, and American disillusionment. Side one functions as a seamless sonic suite, while side two delivers massive radio anthems that define the late 1960s era.

๐Ÿ”Š PREVIEW TOP TRACKS โŒ„
โ™ซ America
โ™ซ Mrs. Robinson
โ™ซ A Hazy Shade of Winter
๐Ÿชฉ Vinyl Pressing & Mastering Notes: Original stereo pressings are widely available, but clean mono copies offer a punchier rhythm section.
#3 Essential Pick

Simon & Garfunkel โ€” Parsley, Sage, Rosemary and Thyme

Label: Columbia • Released: 1966

Simon & Garfunkel โ€” Parsley, Sage, Rosemary and Thyme

Label: Columbia • Released: 1966

This is the record where Paul Simon fully blossomed into one of modern music’s premier lyricists. The duo’s vocal harmonies achieve sublime heights, balancing delicate folk ballads with vibrant pop melodies.

๐Ÿ”Š PREVIEW TOP TRACKS โŒ„
โ™ซ Scarborough Fair / Canticle
โ™ซ Homeward Bound
โ™ซ The 59th Street Bridge Song (Feelin’ Groovy)
๐Ÿชฉ Vinyl Pressing & Mastering Notes: Early stereo 360 Sound Columbia vinyl copies sound exceptionally warm and bring out rich acoustic guitar details.
#4 Essential Pick

Simon & Garfunkel โ€” Sounds of Silence

Label: Columbia • Released: 1966

Simon & Garfunkel โ€” Sounds of Silence

Label: Columbia • Released: 1966

Assembled after producer Tom Wilson added electric instruments to the title track, this album birthed their signature folk-rock sound. It captures mid-60s poetic youth culture with unforgettable acoustic melodies.

๐Ÿ”Š PREVIEW TOP TRACKS โŒ„
โ™ซ The Sound of Silence
โ™ซ Kathy’s Song
โ™ซ I Am a Rock
๐Ÿชฉ Vinyl Pressing & Mastering Notes: The mono mix provides a cohesive, tight soundstage that avoids early wide-panned stereo separation.
#5 Essential Pick

Simon & Garfunkel โ€” Wednesday Morning, 3 A.M.

Label: Columbia • Released: 1964

Simon & Garfunkel โ€” Wednesday Morning, 3 A.M.

Label: Columbia • Released: 1964

Their understated acoustic debut presents pure traditional folk roots before folk-rock fame hit. While less adventurous than their later works, the raw vocal blend and intimate feel make it essential for fans.

๐Ÿ”Š PREVIEW TOP TRACKS โŒ„
โ™ซ You Can Tell the World
โ™ซ Bleecker Street
โ™ซ He Was My Brother
๐Ÿชฉ Vinyl Pressing & Mastering Notes: Standard 1970s Columbia repressings are easy to find, affordable, and sound very clean.
๐Ÿ“ฉ

Donโ€™t Miss a Beat

Get our latest vinyl reviews, curated album lists, and hidden gem recommendations delivered straight to your inbox every week. No spamโ€”just good music.

๐Ÿ”’ 100% Free & No Spam. Unsubscribe at any time.

Vinyl Crate-Digging & Buying Guide

When hunting for Simon & Garfunkel on vinyl, keep an eye out for clean 1960s and 1970s Columbia pressings. Because their music relies heavily on delicate acoustic guitars and subtle vocal dynamics, finding quiet copies without excessive surface noise makes a huge difference. Look out for red Columbia labels with white rim text or vintage 360 Sound labels for classic warmth.

Final Thoughts

Simon & Garfunkel left behind one of the most flawless studio discographies in modern music. From acoustic coffeehouse folk to grand pop-orchestral suites, every album holds a unique magic. Grab your favorite record, drop the needle, and let those incredible harmonies fill the room!